Design engineering approach to ensuring specified dependability. Case study of unique, highly critical systems with short operation life

Aim. To examine the design engineering approach to ensuring specified dependability on the basis of engineering disciplines and design engineering methods of quality and dependability assurance using the case of unique, highly critical products with short operation life. Such approach, unlike the statistical procedures of modern dependability, allows associating the dependability indicator calculations with the calculated operability parameters and established design criteria that are to be met in order to confirm the specified dependability indicators for products with an indefinite number of critical elements, each of which operates according to a functional principle that is different in its nature. Methods. The paper examined the prerequisites for the implementation of the design engineering approach to dependability, such as the distinctive features of ensuring the dependability of unique, highly critical products with short operation life, the applicability of design engineering approach to dependability, the effect of the genesis on the assurance of design engineering dependability, behavioural models of technical products in terms of dependability and specifics of highly critical product calculation. It was identified that, for items with high specified probability of no failure exceeding three-sigma random value variation interval, dependability is to be calculated not by identifying the dependability function, but rather by proving that undependability function is below the acceptable value, which ultimately ensures the specified dependability. Such approach enables the development of methods of early failure prevention using procedures of design engineering analysis of dependability for the purpose of achieving the required parameters of functionality, operability and dependability of products on the basis of a generalised parametric functional model. Results. The design engineering analysis of dependability allows substantiating the criteria for error-free design (selection of sound principles of operability and validation of engineering solutions for achieving the required dependability indicators). The effect of the error-free engineering criteria combined with the criteria for defect-free engineering (observance of the generally accepted principles, rules, requirements, norms and standards of drawing generation) and defect-free manufacture (strict adherence to the requirements of drawings with no deviation permits) enables a designer to achieve the specified dependability values without using the statistical methods of the modern dependability theory. Conclusion. Dependability as a comprehensive property is characterised by a probability that, on the one hand, determines the rate of possible failures, and, on the other hand, indicates the number of errors that were made by engineers during the design, manufacture and operation of products and can lead to failures. Additionally, the failure rate is determined by the engineers’ efforts to eliminate or mitigate the consequences of possible failures at each life cycle stage. The greater and earlier are such efforts adopted, the higher the product’s dependability will be. Ultimately, dependability is determined by consistent and rigorous implementation of error-free design, defect-free design and defect-free manufacture procedures whose efficiency is in no way associated with the number of manufactured products. Their efficiency and effectiveness are determined by specific decisions and actions by the engineers who make sure that the product performs the required functions with the specified dependability in the established modes and conditions of operation. Ensuring that only takes using engineering disciplines, as well as design engineering methods for quality and dependability assurance.

1. Conley P.L., editor. Space Vehicle Mechanisms – Elements of Successful Design. NJ: John Wiley & Sons; 1998.

2. GOST 27.002-89. Industrial product dependability. General principles. Terms and definitions. Moscow: Izdatelstvo Standartov; 1990. (in Russ.)

3. Biriukov G.P., Kukushkin Yu.F., Torpachev A.V. [Fundamentals of dependability and safety of launch facilities]. Moscow: MAI Publishing; 2002. (in Russ.)

4. Polovko А.М., Gurov S.V. [Foundations of the dependability theory]. Saint Petersburg: BHV-Peterburg; 2006. (in Russ.)

5. Pokhabov Yu.P. [Design engineering analysis of dependability. Guidelines. Case study of spacecraft separation system]. Zheleznogorsk: AO NPO PM MKB; 2020. [Issued certificate of copyright registration no. 3644 of 27.05.2020 registered by OOO Sibkopirait, Novosibirsk]. [accessed 20.10.2021]. Available at: https://gnedenko.net. (in Russ.)

6. Pokhabov Yu.P., Ushakov I.A. [On the fail-safety of unique highly critical systems]. Metody menedzhmenta kachestva 2014;11:50-56. (in Russ.)

7. Pokhabov Yu.P. On the dependability of highly critical non-recoverable space entities with short operation life. Case study of single-use mechanical devices. Dependability 2021;21(3):3-12.

8. Artyushenko A.G., Pokhabov Yu.P. Design and technology reliability analysis: fork. IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering 2020;862(2):022001(1–6). doi: 10.1088/1757-899X/862/2/022001.

9. Bolotin V.V. [Application of probability theory and dependability theory methods in structural analysis]. Moscow: Izdatelstvo literatury po stroitelstvu; 1971. (in Russ.)

10. Always P. Rockets of the world. Saturn Press; 1999.

11. Fortescue P., Stark J., Swinerd G. Spacecraft Systems Engineering. NJ: John Wiley & Sons; 2003.

12. Testoyedov N.A., Kosenko V.E., Vygonsky Yu.G. et al. [Space relay systems]. Moscow: Radiotekhnika; 2017. (in Russ.)

13. Fusaro R.L. NASA Space Mechanisms Handbook – Lessons Learned Documented. Research & Technology 1998. NASA/TM 1999:138–140.

14. Shapiro W. et al. Space Mechanisms Lessons Learned Study, Volume I – Summary. NASA/TM-107046; 1995.

15. Shapiro W. et al. Space Mechanisms Lessons Learned Study, Volume II – Literature Review. NASA/ TM-107047; 1995.

16. Gore B.W. Critical Clearances in Space Vehicles. The Aerospace Corporation ATR-2009(9369)-1; 2008.

17. Harland D.M., Lorenz R.D. Space systems failures: disasters and rescues of satellites, rockets and space probes. Berlin: Springer; 2005.

18. Shtokal A.O., Rykov E.V., Dobrosovestnov K.B. et al. Ways of dependability enhancement of spacecraft deployment units with suspended actuation operating. Vestnik NPO im. S.А. Lavochkina 2017;4:60-67. (in Russ.)

19. Merstallinger A., Sales M., Semerad E. et al. Assessment of Cold Welding between Separable Contact Surfaces due to Impact and Fretting under Vacuum. ESA STM-279. Nordwijk; 2009.

20. Pokhabov Yu.P., Makarov V.P., Kolobov A.Yu. et al. [Aspects of ensuring the operational dependability of the mechanical devices for deployment and locking of landing module structures]. Aktualnye voprosy proektirovaniya kosmicheskikh sistem i kompleksov. Sbornik nauchnykh trudov 2019;20:151-166. (in Russ.)

21. Kuznetsov A.A. [Structural dependability of ballistic missiles]. Moscow: Mashinostroenie; 1978. (in Russ.)

22. Kuznetsov A.A., Zolotov A.A., Komyagin V.A. et al. [Dependability of mechanical parts of aircraft design]. Moscow: Mashinostroenie; 1979. (in Russ.)

23. Pokhabov Yu.P. [Theory and practice of ensuring the dependability of single-use mechanical devices]. Krasnoyarsk: SFU; 2018. (in Russ.)

24. Saleh J.H., Caster J.-F. Reliability and multi-state failures: a statistical approach. First Edition. NJ: John Wiley & Sons; 2011.

25. [Failures of rocket and space technology]. [Launch vehicles, satellites, planes, devices: website]. [accessed 20.10.2021]. Available at: http://ecoruspace.me. (in Russ.)

26. Levenchuk А. [Systems engineering thinking in life cycle management]. [accessed 20.10.2021]. Available at: https://ailev.livejournal.com/1121478.html. (in Russ.)

27. Hecht H., Hecht M. Reliability prediction for spacecraft, Report prepared for Rome Air Development Center: no. RADC-TR-85-229, Dec. Rome Air Development Center; 1985.

28. Tumanov A.V., Zelentsov V.V., Shcheglov G.A. [Fundamentals of spacecraft on-board equipment layout design]. Moscow: Bauman MSTU Publishing; 2010. (in Russ.)

29. Sevastianov N.N., Andreev A.I. [Fundamentals of dependability management of spacecraft with long service life]. Tomsk: TSU Publishing; 2015. (in Russ.)

30. Van-Jelen V. [Physical theory of dependability]. Simferopol: Krym; 1998 [Russian].

31. Kurylenko A.M., Ledovsky A.D. [Quality of ship dynamic control systems]. Saint Petersburg: Sudostroyenie; 1994. (in Russ.)

32. Kuleshov A.P. To overcome the resistance of materials: February 2, 2018 interview]. Stimul: zhurnal ob innovatsiyakh v Rossii. [accesed 20.10.2021]. https://stimul.online/articles/interview/preodolet-soprotivleniematerialov/?sphrase_id=1295. (in Russ.)

33. Pokhabov Yu.P. Dependability in digital technology. Dependability 2020;2:3-11.

34. Pokhabov Yu.P. Dependability from a designer’s standpoint. Dependability 2020;4:13-20.

35. Haeder H. Konstruieren und Rechnen für Praxis und Schule. Saint Petersburg: Izdatelstvo K. Rikkera; 1904.

36. Berg A.I. [Selected works]. Energia; 1964. (in Russ.)

37. Bolotin V.V. [Theory of dependability of mechanical systems with a finite number of degrees of freedom]. Izvestiya AN SSSR. Mechanics of solids 1969;5:74-81. (in Russ.)

38. Pronikov A.S. [Parametric dependability of machines]. Moscow: Bauman MSTU Publishing; 2002. (in Russ.)

39. Pronikov A.S. [Dependability of machines]. Mos-cow: Mashinostroenie; 1978. (in Russ.)

40. Ushakov I.A. [Dependability: past, present, future: keynote speech of the opening of Mathematical Methods in Reliability (MMR–2000) conference, Bordeau, France, 2000]. Reliability: Theory & Applications 2016;1(1):17-27. (accessed 20.10.2021). Available at: http://www.gnedenko.net/Journal/2006/RTA_1_2006.pdf. (in Russ.)

41. Plahotnikova E.V., Safonov A.S., Ushakov M.V. The design of products with requirements of reliability parameters. Izvestiya TulGU: Teknicheskie nauki 2015;7(1):134-139. (in Russ.)

42. Yendogur A.I. [Aeronautical structure design. Structural design of parts and units]. Moscow: Izdatelstvo MAI-PRINT; 2009. (in Russ.)

43. Orlov P.I. Uchaev P.N., editor. Introduction into design in 2 volumes. Volume 1]. Moscow: Mashinostoenie; 1988. (in Russ.)

44. Khoroshev A.N. [Introduction into the design management of mechanical systems]. Belgorod; 1999. (in Russ.)

45. Lelikov O.P. [Fundamentals of calculation and design of machine parts and assemblies]. Moscow: Mashinostroenie; 2007. (in Russ.)

46. Bushuev V.V. [Practice of machine design]. Mos-cow: Mashonostrienie; 2006. (in Russ.)

47. Timoshenkov S.P., Simonov B.M., Goroshko V.N. [Fundamentals of the dependability theory]. Moscow: Yurait; 2015. (in Russ.)

48. Patraev V.E., Khalimanovich V.I. [Dependability of support spacecraft]. Krasnoyarsk: SibGAU; 2016. (in Russ.)

49. Venikov G.V. [Dependability and design]. Mos-cow: Znanie; 1971. (in Russ.)

50. Gorokhova V.V. [Application of the Saratov system in research and design]. Moscow: Izdatelstvo standartov; 1969. (in Russ.)

51. Dubovikov B.A. [Fundamentals of scientific quality management (practical experience and theoretical substantiation of the system for defect-free work organization). Moscow: Ekonomika; 1966. (in Russ.)

52. GOST 27.002-2015. Dependability in technics. General principles. Terms and definitions. Moscow: Standartinform; 2016. (in Russ.)

53. Borovkov A.I., Riabov Yu.A., Kukushkin K.V. et al. [Digital twins and the digital transformation of defense industry companies]. Oboronnaya tekhnika 2018;1:6-33. (in Russ.)