Possible ways of improving the reliability of professional psychological selection of air traffic controllers

Aim. The paper examines one of the possible ways of improving the reliability of professional psychological selection of air traffic controllers using diagnostic methods based on not subjective, but rather objective principles. Methods. The research used the following: Tobii REX fixed eye tracker and a specialized computer product developed by the All-Russian Scientific Research Institute of Radio Equipment and intended for the analysis of various aspects of eye movements in the process of exercise, as well as a range of psychodiagnostic methods: level of subjective control identification test, Buss-Durkee Hostility Inventory, ММ-1 socionic test, H.J. Eysenck’s intelligence test, H.J. Eysenck’s personality inventory test, ММYa-1 general mode test, K. Thomas’ conflict mode questionnaire and the Prognoz questionnaire for neuropsychicstability evaluation of experimental subjects. Statistical processing of the findings was done using the Bravais-Pearson correlation coefficient and Pearson’s chi-squared test. Results. The experiment involved 48 third year students of the Saint Petersburg State University of Civil Aviation (SPBGU GA) majoring in Organization of Airspace Management. In terms of its psychological characteristics, the group is quite typical for this major of SPBGU GA. The results of psychodiagnostics do not correlate well with the results of this experiment, while among each other, in general, they match the theoretical assumption. The lower the neurotism which characterizes the balance of the nervous system, the better is the neuropsychicstability. The better is the neuropsychicstability, the higher the internality of any kind, especially general internality and internality for failure. People with good neuropsychicstability are also less inclined to aggressive behaviour, both in general as regards all of its kinds, and especially self-aggression. As expected, subjects with high levels of general internality turned out to be positively not inclined to such type of behaviour in conflict as “avoidance” that is the quintessence of irresponsibility. Also, people with high internality turned out to be not inclined to aggressive behaviour. The experiment exposed quite contradictory patterns of eye movement in the subjects. Conclusions. All the findings are of certain interest. Therefore, despite them being somewhat contradictory, it appears to be advisable to continue the research using the Tobii REX eye tracker. The identified shortcomings in the experiment organization allowed making corrections to the plan of further research based on the use of the Tobii REX eye tracker and aimed at improving the reliability of professional psychological selection. 

1. Air transportation system, ; [accessed 27.10.2017]. 2. Near collision in India, [accessed 27.10.2017].

2. Analiz sostoyaniya bezopasnosti poletov v grazhdanskoy aviatsii Rossiyskoy Federatsii v 2015 godu [Analysis of the civilian air safety in the Russian Federation in 2015]. Moscow: FAVT; 2016 [in Russian].

3. Analiz sostoyaniya bezopasnosti poletov v grazhdanskoy aviatsii Rossiyskoy Federatsii v pervom polugodii 2016 goda [Analysis of the civilian air safety in the Russian Federation in the first half of 2016]. Moscow: FAVT; 2016 [in Russian].

4. Sostoyanie bezopasnosti poletov v grazhdanskoy aviatsii gosudarstv-uchastnikov soglasheniya o grazhdanskoy aviatsii i ob ispolzovanii vozdushnogo prostranstva v 2015 godu [Civilian air safety in the member nations of the agreement on civilian aviation and airspace management in 2015]. Moscow: IAC, 2016 [in Russian].

5. Arinicheva OV, Kovalenko GV, Malishevsky AV, Mikhalchevsky YuYu. Vzaimodeystvie ekipazha vozdushnogo sudna so sluzhboy upravleniya vozdushnym dvizheniem: sotsionicheskiy aspekt problemy [Interaction between the flight crew and the air traffic control service: the socionic aspect of the subject]. Herald of the Saint Petersburg State University of Civil Aviation 2016;4(13):5-16 [in Russian].

6. Malishevsky AV, Vlasov EV, Kaymakova EM. Vozmozhnye puti resheniya problemy snizheniya negativnogo vliyaniya chelovecheskogo faktora v chrezvychaynykh situatsiyakh na transporte [Possible ways of reducing the negative effect of the human factor in transportation emergencies]. Biomedical and psychosocial aspects of safety in emergency situations 2015;1:108-114 [in Russian].

7. Malishevsky AV, Arinicheva OV, Vlasov EV. Vozmozhnye puti resheniya problemy snizheniya negativnogo vliyaniya chelovecheskogo faktora na bezopasnost poliotov [Possible ways of reducing the negative effect of the human factor on flight safety]. Transport: science, equipment, management 2016;2:12-20 [in Russian].

8. Arinicheva OV, Kovalenko GV, Malishevsky AV, Mikhalchevsky YuYu. Analiz dinamicheskoy vozdushnoy obstanovki [Analysis of dynamic air environment]. Problemy liotnoy ekspluatatsii i bezopasnost poliotov [Matters of flight operation and air safety] 2016;10:85-119 [in Russian].

9. Maklakov AG. Professionalny psikhologicheskiy otbor personala [Professional psychological selection of personnel]. Teoria i praktika: ouchebnik dlia vuzov [Theory and practice: textbook for higher educational institutions]. Saint-Petersburg: Piter; 2008 [in Russian].

10. Rukovodstvo po psikhologicheskomu obespecheniyu otbora, podgotovki i professionalnoy deyatelnosti letnogo i dispetcherskogo sostava grazhdanskoy aviatsii Rossiyskoy Federatsii [Guidelines for psychological support of selection, training and professional activity of flying and control personnel of civilian aviation of the Russian Federation]. Moscow: Vozdushny transport; 2001 [in Russian].

11. Arinicheva OV, Malishevsky AV. Nedostatki sushchestvuyushchego professionalnogo otbora pilotov i problema ego sovershenstvovaniya [Disadvantages of the existing professional selection of pilots and matters of its improvement]. Transport: science, equipment, management 2016;6:41-51 [in Russian].

12. Mikhailik NF, Malishevsky AV. Kontseptsiya natsionalnoy sistemy spetsialnoy psikhologicheskoy podgotovki letnogo sostava [Concept of a national system of special psychological training of flying personnel]. Prikladnaya psikhologia [Applied psychology] 1999;4:30-44 [in Russian].

13. Burlachuk LF. Slovar-spravochnik po psikhodiagnostike [Dictionary and handbook of psychodiagnostics]. Saint-Petersburg: Piter; 2008 [in Russian].

14. Arinicheva OV, Gerasimenkova AE, Chepik MG. Vliyanie gendernykh razlichiy v khode eksperimenta s ispolzovaniem oborudovaniya Eye Tracker Tobii REX [The effect of gender differences during an experiment involving Eye Tracker Tobii REX]. Problemy liotnoy ekspluatatsii i bezopasnost poliotov [Matters of flight operation and air safety] 2017;11:137-146 [in Russian].

15. Arinicheva OV, Gerasimenkova AE, Malishevsky AV, Mikhalchevsky YuYu, Chepik MG. Issledovanie professionalno vazhnykh kachestv dispetchera po OVD s ispolzovaniem oborudovaniya Eye Tracker Tobii REX [Research of professionally significant qualities of air traffic controllers using Eye Tracker Tobii REX]. Problemy liotnoy ekspluatatsii i bezopasnost poliotov [Matters of flight operation and air safety] 2017;11:113-120 [in Russian].

16. Gerasimenkova AE, Girenko IYu, Dibrova AA, Lysanova EYu, Chepik MG. Issledovanie professionalno vazhnykh kachestv dispetchera po OVD s ispolzovaniem psikhodiagnostiki [Research of professionally significant qualities of air traffic controllers using psychopdiagnostics]. Problemy liotnoy ekspluatatsii i bezopasnost poliotov [Matters of flight operation and air safety] 2017;11:155-163 [in Russian].

17. Prokhorov AO, editor. Praktikum po psikhologii sostoyaniy: oucheb. posob. [Tutorial on the psychology of states: a study guide]. Saint-Petersburg: Rech; 2004 [in Russian].

18. Malishevsky AV. Nekotorye voprosy sovershenstvovaniya sotsionicheskoy psikhodiagnostiki aviatsionnogo personala [Some matters regarding the improvement of socionic psychodiagnostics of aeronautical personnel]. Transport: science, equipment, management 2017;2:23-30 [in Russian].

19. Eysenck HJ. Check Your Own I.Q. Moscow: EKSMO-Press; 2003.

20. Sidorenko EV. Metody matematicheskoy obrabotki v psikhologii [Methods of mathematical processing in psychology]. Saint-Petersburg: Rech; 2007 [in Russian].

21. Arinicheva OV. Analiz diagnostiki intellektualnykh sposobnostey budushchikh aviatsionnykh spetsialistov [Analysis of intellectual abilities diagnostics of future aeronautic personnel]. Transport: science, equipment, management 2017;2:15-22 [in Russian].

22. Kakoy IQ u Alberta Eynshteyna? [What is Albert Einstein’s IQ?], ; [accessed 27.10.2017].

23. Arinicheva OV. Issledovanie intellektualnykh sposobnostey studentov universiteta grazhdanskoy aviatsii [Research of the intellectual abilities of the civilian aviation university students]. Herald of the Saint Petersburg State University of Civil Aviation 2016;4(13):38-57 [in Russian].

24. Danilov DV. Bezopasnost politov [Air safety]. Electronic study guide. Samara: Samara State Aerospace University; 2012 [in Russian].